| A25 | 61 | Horseshoe Crab | Creature — Crab | | |
| A25 | 62 | Jace, the Mind Sculptor | Legendary Planeswalker — Jace | | |
| A25 | 63 | Jalira, Master Polymorphist | Legendary Creature — Human Wizard | | |
| A25 | 64 | Man-o'-War | Creature — Jellyfish | | |
| A25 | 65 | Merfolk Looter | Creature — Merfolk Rogue | | |
| A25 | 66 | Murder of Crows | Creature — Bird | | |
| A25 | 67 | Mystic of the Hidden Way | Creature — Human Monk | | |
| A25 | 68 | Pact of Negation | Instant | | |
| A25 | 69 | Phantasmal Bear | Creature — Bear Illusion | | |
| A25 | 70 | Reef Worm | Creature — Worm | | |
| A25 | 71 | Retraction Helix | Instant | | |
| A25 | 72 | Shoreline Ranger | Creature — Bird Soldier Ranger | | |
| A25 | 73 | Sift | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 74 | Totally Lost | Instant | | |
| A25 | 75 | Twisted Image | Instant | | |
| A25 | 76 | Vendilion Clique | Legendary Creature — Faerie Wizard | | |
| A25 | 77 | Vesuvan Shapeshifter | Creature — Shapeshifter | | |
| A25 | 78 | Willbender | Creature — Human Wizard | | |
| A25 | 79 | Ancient Craving | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 80 | Bloodhunter Bat | Creature — Bat | | |
| A25 | 81 | Caustic Tar | Enchantment — Aura | | |
| A25 | 82 | Dark Ritual | Instant | | |
| A25 | 83 | Deadly Designs | Enchantment | | |
| A25 | 84 | Death's-Head Buzzard | Creature — Bird | | |
| A25 | 85 | Diabolic Edict | Instant | | |
| A25 | 86 | Dirge of Dread | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 87 | Disfigure | Instant | | |
| A25 | 88 | Doomsday | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 89 | Dusk Legion Zealot | Creature — Vampire Soldier | | |
| A25 | 90 | Erg Raiders | Creature — Human Warrior | | |
| A25 | 91 | Fallen Angel | Creature — Angel | | |
| A25 | 92 | Hell's Caretaker | Creature — Horror | | |
| A25 | 93 | Horror of the Broken Lands | Creature — Horror | | |
| A25 | 94 | Ihsan's Shade | Legendary Creature — Shade Knight | | |
| A25 | 95 | Laquatus's Champion | Creature — Nightmare Horror | | |
| A25 | 96 | Living Death | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 97 | Mesmeric Fiend | Creature — Nightmare Horror | | |
| A25 | 98 | Murder | Instant | | |
| A25 | 99 | Nezumi Cutthroat | Creature — Rat Warrior | | |
| A25 | 100 | Phyrexian Ghoul | Creature — Phyrexian Zombie | | |
| A25 | 101 | Phyrexian Obliterator | Creature — Phyrexian Horror | | |
| A25 | 102 | Plague Wind | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 103 | Ratcatcher | Creature — Ogre Rogue | | |
| A25 | 104 | Ravenous Chupacabra | Creature — Beast Horror | | |
| A25 | 105 | Relentless Rats | Creature — Rat | | |
| A25 | 106 | Returned Phalanx | Creature — Zombie Soldier | | |
| A25 | 107 | Ruthless Ripper | Creature — Human Assassin | | |
| A25 | 108 | Street Wraith | Creature — Wraith | | |
| A25 | 109 | Supernatural Stamina | Instant | | |
| A25 | 110 | Triskaidekaphobia | Enchantment | | |
| A25 | 111 | Twisted Abomination | Creature — Zombie Mutant | | |
| A25 | 112 | Undead Gladiator | Creature — Zombie Barbarian | | |
| A25 | 113 | Unearth | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 114 | Vampire Lacerator | Creature — Vampire Warrior | | |
| A25 | 115 | Will-o'-the-Wisp | Creature — Spirit | | |
| A25 | 116 | Zombify | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 117 | Zulaport Cutthroat | Creature — Human Rogue Ally | | |
| A25 | 118 | Act of Treason | Sorcery | | |
| A25 | 119 | Akroma, Angel of Fury | Legendary Creature — Angel | | |
| A25 | 120 | Balduvian Horde | Creature — Human Barbarian | | |