| Set | Nº | Name | Type | Mana Cost | Colors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OTJ | 1 | Another Round | Sorcery | | |
| OTJ | 2 | Archangel of Tithes | Creature — Angel | | |
| OTJ | 3 | Armored Armadillo | Creature — Armadillo | | |
| OTJ | 4 | Aven Interrupter | Creature — Bird Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 5 | Bounding Felidar | Creature — Cat Beast Mount | | |
| OTJ | 6 | Bovine Intervention | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 7 | Bridled Bighorn | Creature — Sheep Mount | | |
| OTJ | 8 | Claim Jumper | Creature — Rabbit Mercenary | | |
| OTJ | 9 | Dust Animus | Creature — Spirit | | |
| OTJ | 10 | Eriette's Lullaby | Sorcery | | |
| OTJ | 11 | Final Showdown | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 12 | Fortune, Loyal Steed | Legendary Creature — Beast Mount | | |
| OTJ | 13 | Frontier Seeker | Creature — Human Scout | | |
| OTJ | 14 | Getaway Glamer | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 15 | High Noon | Enchantment | | |
| OTJ | 16 | Holy Cow | Creature — Ox Angel | | |
| OTJ | 17 | Inventive Wingsmith | Creature — Dwarf Artificer | | |
| OTJ | 18 | Lassoed by the Law | Enchantment | | |
| OTJ | 19 | Mystical Tether | Enchantment | | |
| OTJ | 20 | Nurturing Pixie | Creature — Faerie Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 21 | Omenport Vigilante | Creature — Human Mercenary | | |
| OTJ | 22 | One Last Job | Sorcery | | |
| OTJ | 23 | Outlaw Medic | Creature — Human Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 24 | Prairie Dog | Creature — Squirrel | | |
| OTJ | 25 | Prosperity Tycoon | Creature — Human Noble | | |
| OTJ | 26 | Requisition Raid | Sorcery | | |
| OTJ | 27 | Rustler Rampage | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 28 | Shepherd of the Clouds | Creature — Pegasus | | |
| OTJ | 29 | Sheriff of Safe Passage | Creature — Human Knight | | |
| OTJ | 30 | Stagecoach Security | Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| OTJ | 31 | Steer Clear | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 32 | Sterling Keykeeper | Creature — Human Mercenary | | |
| OTJ | 33 | Sterling Supplier | Creature — Bird Soldier | | |
| OTJ | 34 | Take Up the Shield | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 35 | Thunder Lasso | Artifact — Equipment | | |
| OTJ | 36 | Trained Arynx | Creature — Cat Beast Mount | | |
| OTJ | 37 | Vengeful Townsfolk | Creature — Human Citizen | | |
| OTJ | 38 | Wanted Griffin | Creature — Griffin | | |
| OTJ | 39 | Archmage's Newt | Creature — Salamander Mount | | |
| OTJ | 40 | Canyon Crab | Creature — Crab | | |
| OTJ | 41 | Daring Thunder-Thief | Creature — Turtle Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 42 | Deepmuck Desperado | Creature — Homarid Mercenary | | |
| OTJ | 43 | Djinn of Fool's Fall | Creature — Djinn | | |
| OTJ | 44 | Double Down | Enchantment | | |
| OTJ | 45 | Duelist of the Mind | Creature — Human Advisor | | |
| OTJ | 46 | Emergent Haunting | Enchantment | | |
| OTJ | 47 | Failed Fording | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 48 | Fblthp, Lost on the Range | Legendary Creature — Homunculus | | |
| OTJ | 49 | Fleeting Reflection | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 50 | Geralf, the Fleshwright | Legendary Creature — Human Warlock | | |
| OTJ | 51 | Geyser Drake | Creature — Drake | | |
| OTJ | 52 | Harrier Strix | Creature — Bird | | |
| OTJ | 53 | Jailbreak Scheme | Sorcery | | |
| OTJ | 54 | The Key to the Vault | Legendary Artifact — Equipment | | |
| OTJ | 55 | Loan Shark | Creature — Shark Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 56 | Marauding Sphinx | Creature — Sphinx Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 57 | Metamorphic Blast | Instant | | |
| OTJ | 58 | Nimble Brigand | Creature — Human Rogue | | |
| OTJ | 59 | Outlaw Stitcher | Creature — Human Warlock | | |
| OTJ | 60 | Peerless Ropemaster | Creature — Human Rogue | | |