| Set | Nº | Name | Type | Mana Cost | Colors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HHO | 6 | Fruitcake Elemental | Creature — Elemental | ||
| HHO | 7 | Gifts Given | Instant | ||
| HHO | 7† | Gifts Given | Instant | ||
| HHO | 8 | Evil Presents | Sorcery | ||
| HHO | 9 | Season's Beatings | Sorcery | ||
| HHO | 10 | Snow Mercy | Snow Enchantment | ||
| HHO | 11 | Yule Ooze | Creature — Ooze | ||
| HHO | 12 | Naughty // Nice | Sorcery | ||
| HHO | 13 | Stocking Tiger | Artifact Creature — Cat Construct | ||
| HHO | 13† | Stocking Tiger | Artifact Creature — Cat Construct | ||
| HHO | 14 | Mishra's Toy Workshop | Land | ||
| HHO | 15 | Goblin Sleigh Ride | Sorcery | ||
| HHO | 16 | Thopter Pie Network | Enchantment | ||
| HHO | 17 | Some Disassembly Required | Enchantment | ||
| HHO | 18 | Bog Humbugs | Creature — Insect | ||
| HHO | 19 | Decorated Knight // Present Arms | Creature — Human Knight | ||
| HHO | 20 | Topdeck the Halls | Enchantment | ||
| HHO | 21 | Last-Minute Chopping | Sorcery | ||
| HHO | 22 | Chaos Wrap | Instant | ||
| HHO | 23 | Seasonal Sequels | Instant | ||
| HHO | 24 | Eggnogger's 'Stache | Artifact | ||
| HHO | 25 | Cheer | Creature — Elemental Incarnation |