| HOC | 1 | Fíli and Kíli, Joyous | Legendary Creature — Dwarf Bard | | |
| HOC | 2 | Gandalf, Party Guest | Legendary Creature — Avatar Wizard | | |
| HOC | 3 | Thorin, King of Durin's Folk | Legendary Creature — Dwarf Noble | | |
| HOC | 4 | Bilbo, Fellow Conspirator | Legendary Creature — Halfling Citizen | | |
| HOC | 5 | Bag End Banquet | Artifact | | |
| HOC | 6 | Ori, Plate Stacker | Legendary Creature — Dwarf Bard | | |
| HOC | 7 | Long-Lost Lances | Artifact — Equipment | | |
| HOC | 8 | Dragon-Cursed Halls | Land | | |
| HOC | 9 | Smaug the Impenetrable | Legendary Creature — Dragon | | |
| HOC | 10 | Bilbo's Burglaring | Sorcery | | |
| HOC | 11 | Dragon's Desire | Sorcery | | |
| HOC | 12 | Necklace of Girion | Legendary Artifact | | |
| HOC | 13 | Dawn of a New Age | Enchantment | | |
| HOC | 14 | Flowering of the White Tree | Legendary Enchantment | | |
| HOC | 15 | The Gaffer | Legendary Creature — Halfling Peasant | | |
| HOC | 16 | Galadriel's Dismissal | Instant | | |
| HOC | 17 | Reprieve | Instant | | |
| HOC | 18 | Raise the Palisade | Sorcery | | |
| HOC | 19 | Orcish Bowmasters | Creature — Orc Archer | | |
| HOC | 20 | Witch-king of Angmar | Legendary Creature — Wraith Noble | | |
| HOC | 21 | Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin | Legendary Creature — Wraith Noble | | |
| HOC | 22 | Call Forth the Tempest | Sorcery | | |
| HOC | 23 | Cavern-Hoard Dragon | Creature — Dragon | | |
| HOC | 24 | Arwen, Weaver of Hope | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| HOC | 25 | Delighted Halfling | Creature — Halfling Citizen | | |
| HOC | 26 | Elven Chorus | Enchantment | | |
| HOC | 27 | Last March of the Ents | Sorcery | | |
| HOC | 28 | Aragorn and Arwen, Wed | Legendary Creature — Human Elf Noble | | |
| HOC | 29 | Aragorn, the Uniter | Legendary Creature — Human Noble | | |
| HOC | 30 | Arwen, Mortal Queen | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| HOC | 31 | Flame of Anor | Instant | | |
| HOC | 32 | Galadriel, Light of Valinor | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| HOC | 33 | Gríma, Saruman's Footman | Legendary Creature — Human Advisor | | |
| HOC | 34 | Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff | Legendary Creature — Halfling Rogue | | |
| HOC | 35 | Saruman of Many Colors | Legendary Creature — Avatar Wizard | | |
| HOC | 36 | Sauron, the Dark Lord | Legendary Creature — Avatar Horror | | |
| HOC | 37 | Sauron, the Lidless Eye | Legendary Creature — Avatar Horror | | |
| HOC | 38 | Tom Bombadil | Legendary Creature — God Bard | | |
| HOC | 39 | Andúril, Flame of the West | Legendary Artifact — Equipment | | |
| HOC | 40 | Andúril, Narsil Reforged | Legendary Artifact — Equipment | | |
| HOC | 41 | Bilbo's Ring | Legendary Artifact — Equipment | | |
| HOC | 42 | Glamdring | Legendary Artifact — Equipment | | |
| HOC | 43 | Mithril Coat | Legendary Artifact — Equipment | | |
| HOC | 44 | The One Ring | Legendary Artifact | | |
| HOC | 45 | Palantír of Orthanc | Legendary Artifact | | |
| HOC | 46 | Relic of Sauron | Artifact | | |
| HOC | 47 | The Black Gate | Legendary Land — Gate | | |
| HOC | 48 | Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress | Legendary Land | | |
| HOC | 49 | Minas Tirith | Legendary Land | | |
| HOC | 50 | Mount Doom | Legendary Land | | |
| HOC | 51 | Rivendell | Legendary Land | | |
| HOC | 52 | The Shire | Legendary Land | | |
| HOC | 53 | Dawn of a New Age | Enchantment | | |
| HOC | 54 | Flowering of the White Tree | Legendary Enchantment | | |
| HOC | 55 | The Gaffer | Legendary Creature — Halfling Peasant | | |
| HOC | 56 | Galadriel's Dismissal | Instant | | |
| HOC | 57 | Reprieve | Instant | | |
| HOC | 58 | Raise the Palisade | Sorcery | | |
| HOC | 59 | Orcish Bowmasters | Creature — Orc Archer | | |
| HOC | 60 | Witch-king of Angmar | Legendary Creature — Wraith Noble | | |