| LTC | 1 | Éowyn, Shieldmaiden | Legendary Creature — Human Knight | | |
| LTC | 2 | Frodo, Adventurous Hobbit | Legendary Creature — Halfling Scout | | |
| LTC | 3 | Galadriel, Elven-Queen | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| LTC | 4 | Sauron, Lord of the Rings | Legendary Creature — Avatar Horror | | |
| LTC | 5 | Aragorn, King of Gondor | Legendary Creature — Human Noble | | |
| LTC | 6 | Gandalf, Westward Voyager | Legendary Creature — Avatar Wizard | | |
| LTC | 7 | Sam, Loyal Attendant | Legendary Creature — Halfling Peasant | | |
| LTC | 8 | Saruman, the White Hand | Legendary Creature — Avatar Wizard | | |
| LTC | 9 | Beregond of the Guard | Legendary Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| LTC | 10 | Champions of Minas Tirith | Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| LTC | 11 | Field-Tested Frying Pan | Artifact — Equipment | | |
| LTC | 12 | The Gaffer | Legendary Creature — Halfling Peasant | | |
| LTC | 13 | Gilraen, Dúnedain Protector | Legendary Creature — Human Noble | | |
| LTC | 14 | Grey Host Reinforcements | Creature — Spirit Soldier | | |
| LTC | 15 | Gwaihir, Greatest of the Eagles | Legendary Creature — Bird Noble | | |
| LTC | 16 | Lossarnach Captain | Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| LTC | 17 | Of Herbs and Stewed Rabbit | Enchantment — Saga | | |
| LTC | 18 | Archivist of Gondor | Creature — Human Advisor | | |
| LTC | 19 | Corsairs of Umbar | Creature — Human Pirate | | |
| LTC | 20 | Denethor, Stone Seer | Legendary Creature — Human Noble | | |
| LTC | 21 | Fealty to the Realm | Enchantment — Aura | | |
| LTC | 22 | Monstrosity of the Lake | Legendary Creature — Kraken | | |
| LTC | 23 | Raise the Palisade | Sorcery | | |
| LTC | 24 | Subjugate the Hobbits | Sorcery | | |
| LTC | 25 | Trap the Trespassers | Instant | | |
| LTC | 26 | Gollum, Obsessed Stalker | Legendary Creature — Halfling Horror | | |
| LTC | 27 | Lobelia, Defender of Bag End | Legendary Creature — Halfling Citizen | | |
| LTC | 28 | Rapacious Guest | Creature — Halfling Citizen | | |
| LTC | 29 | Shelob, Dread Weaver | Legendary Creature — Spider Demon | | |
| LTC | 30 | Call for Aid | Sorcery | | |
| LTC | 31 | Cavern-Hoard Dragon | Creature — Dragon | | |
| LTC | 32 | Gimli of the Glittering Caves | Legendary Creature — Dwarf Warrior | | |
| LTC | 33 | Orcish Siegemaster | Creature — Orc Soldier | | |
| LTC | 34 | Rampaging War Mammoth | Creature — Elephant | | |
| LTC | 35 | Arwen, Weaver of Hope | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| LTC | 36 | Assemble the Entmoot | Enchantment | | |
| LTC | 37 | Feasting Hobbit | Creature — Halfling Citizen | | |
| LTC | 38 | Galadhrim Ambush | Instant | | |
| LTC | 39 | Haldir, Lórien Lieutenant | Legendary Creature — Elf Soldier | | |
| LTC | 40 | Legolas Greenleaf | Legendary Creature — Elf Archer | | |
| LTC | 41 | Mirkwood Elk | Creature — Elk | | |
| LTC | 42 | Motivated Pony | Creature — Horse | | |
| LTC | 43 | Prize Pig | Creature — Boar | | |
| LTC | 44 | Travel Through Caradhras | Sorcery | | |
| LTC | 45 | Windswift Slice | Instant | | |
| LTC | 46 | The Balrog of Moria | Legendary Creature — Avatar Demon | | |
| LTC | 47 | Banquet Guests | Creature — Halfling Citizen | | |
| LTC | 48 | Bilbo, Birthday Celebrant | Legendary Creature — Halfling Rogue | | |
| LTC | 49 | Boromir, Gondor's Hope | Legendary Creature — Human Warrior | | |
| LTC | 50 | Círdan the Shipwright | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| LTC | 51 | Elrond of the White Council | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| LTC | 52 | Éomer, King of Rohan | Legendary Creature — Human Noble | | |
| LTC | 53 | Erestor of the Council | Legendary Creature — Elf Noble | | |
| LTC | 54 | Faramir, Steward of Gondor | Legendary Creature — Human Noble | | |
| LTC | 55 | Farmer Cotton | Legendary Creature — Halfling Peasant | | |
| LTC | 56 | Forth Eorlingas! | Sorcery | | |
| LTC | 57 | Gríma, Saruman's Footman | Legendary Creature — Human Advisor | | |
| LTC | 58 | In the Darkness Bind Them | Enchantment — Saga | | |
| LTC | 59 | Lidless Gaze | Sorcery | | |
| LTC | 60 | Lord of the Nazgûl | Legendary Creature — Wraith Noble | | |