| PSOI | 1s | Always Watching | Enchantment | | |
| PSOI | 2 | Angel of Deliverance | Creature — Angel | | |
| PSOI | 2s | Angel of Deliverance | Creature — Angel | | |
| PSOI | 5s | Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier | Legendary Creature — Angel | | |
| PSOI | 8s | Bygone Bishop | Creature — Spirit Cleric | | |
| PSOI | 12s | Declaration in Stone | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 13s | Descend upon the Sinful | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 15 | Drogskol Cavalry | Creature — Spirit Knight | | |
| PSOI | 15s | Drogskol Cavalry | Creature — Spirit Knight | | |
| PSOI | 16p | Eerie Interlude | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 16s | Eerie Interlude | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 21s | Hanweir Militia Captain // Westvale Cult Leader | Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| PSOI | 31s | Odric, Lunarch Marshal | Legendary Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| PSOI | 43s | Thalia's Lieutenant | Creature — Human Soldier | | |
| PSOI | 53s | Confirm Suspicions | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 58s | Engulf the Shore | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 59s | Epiphany at the Drownyard | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 63s | Forgotten Creation | Creature — Zombie Horror | | |
| PSOI | 65s | Geralf's Masterpiece | Creature — Zombie Horror | | |
| PSOI | 69s | Jace, Unraveler of Secrets | Legendary Planeswalker — Jace | | |
| PSOI | 75 | Nephalia Moondrakes | Creature — Drake | | |
| PSOI | 75s | Nephalia Moondrakes | Creature — Drake | | |
| PSOI | 81s | Rattlechains | Creature — Spirit | | |
| PSOI | 88s | Startled Awake // Persistent Nightmare | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 92s | Thing in the Ice // Awoken Horror | Creature — Horror | | |
| PSOI | 96s | Welcome to the Fold | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 99s | Asylum Visitor | Creature — Vampire Wizard | | |
| PSOI | 101s | Behold the Beyond | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 107s | Diregraf Colossus | Creature — Zombie Giant | | |
| PSOI | 108 | Elusive Tormentor // Insidious Mist | Creature — Vampire Wizard | | |
| PSOI | 108s | Elusive Tormentor // Insidious Mist | Creature — Vampire Wizard | | |
| PSOI | 109s | Ever After | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 111s | From Under the Floorboards | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 122 | Markov Dreadknight | Creature — Vampire Knight | | |
| PSOI | 122s | Markov Dreadknight | Creature — Vampire Knight | | |
| PSOI | 124s | Mindwrack Demon | Creature — Demon | | |
| PSOI | 131s | Relentless Dead | Creature — Zombie | | |
| PSOI | 139s | To the Slaughter | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 141s | Triskaidekaphobia | Enchantment | | |
| PSOI | 145s | Avacyn's Judgment | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 148s | Burn from Within | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 151s | Devils' Playground | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 155s | Falkenrath Gorger | Creature — Vampire Berserker | | |
| PSOI | 157 | Flameblade Angel | Creature — Angel | | |
| PSOI | 157s | Flameblade Angel | Creature — Angel | | |
| PSOI | 159s | Geier Reach Bandit // Vildin-Pack Alpha | Creature — Human Rogue Werewolf | | |
| PSOI | 162s | Goldnight Castigator | Creature — Angel | | |
| PSOI | 163s | Harness the Storm | Enchantment | | |
| PSOI | 166 | Incorrigible Youths | Creature — Vampire | | |
| PSOI | 175 | Ravenous Bloodseeker | Creature — Vampire Berserker | | |
| PSOI | 179s | Scourge Wolf | Creature — Wolf Horror | | |
| PSOI | 181s | Sin Prodder | Creature — Devil | | |
| PSOI | 192s | Wolf of Devil's Breach | Creature — Elemental Wolf | | |
| PSOI | 200s | Cryptolith Rite | Enchantment | | |
| PSOI | 202s | Deathcap Cultivator | Creature — Human Druid | | |
| PSOI | 212s | Inexorable Blob | Creature — Ooze | | |
| PSOI | 225s | Sage of Ancient Lore // Werewolf of Ancient Hunger | Creature — Human Shaman Werewolf | | |
| PSOI | 226s | Seasons Past | Sorcery | | |
| PSOI | 227s | Second Harvest | Instant | | |
| PSOI | 228s | Silverfur Partisan | Creature — Wolf Warrior | | |