| TMC | 1 | Leonardo, the Balance | Legendary Creature — Mutant Ninja Turtle | | |
| TMC | 2 | Donatello, the Brains | Legendary Creature — Mutant Ninja Turtle | | |
| TMC | 3 | Splinter, the Mentor | Legendary Creature — Mutant Ninja Rat | | |
| TMC | 4 | Raphael, the Muscle | Legendary Creature — Mutant Ninja Turtle | | |
| TMC | 5 | Michelangelo, the Heart | Legendary Creature — Mutant Ninja Turtle | | |
| TMC | 6 | Heroes in a Half Shell | Legendary Creature — Mutant Ninja Turtle | | |
| TMC | 7 | Continue? | Instant | | |
| TMC | 8 | Endless Foot Assault | Enchantment | | |
| TMC | 9 | April O'Neil, Live on the Scene | Legendary Creature — Human Detective | | |
| TMC | 10 | Baxter, Fly in the Ointment | Legendary Creature — Insect Mutant Scientist | | |
| TMC | 11 | Here Comes a New Hero! | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 12 | Irma, Part-Time Mutant | Legendary Creature — Human Mutant Shapeshifter | | |
| TMC | 13 | Krang, the All-Powerful | Legendary Artifact Creature — Utrom Robot | | |
| TMC | 14 | Ray Fillet, Wave Warrior | Legendary Creature — Fish Mutant | | |
| TMC | 15 | Bebop, Skull & Crossbones | Legendary Creature — Boar Mutant | | |
| TMC | 16 | Dimension X Pizzasaur | Artifact Creature — Food Alien Mutant | | |
| TMC | 17 | Foot Chopper | Artifact — Equipment | | |
| TMC | 18 | Game Over | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 19 | Rat King, Pale Piper | Legendary Creature — Rat Avatar | | |
| TMC | 20 | Shredder, Shadow Master | Legendary Creature — Human Ninja | | |
| TMC | 21 | Swift Demise | Instant | | |
| TMC | 22 | Casey Jones, Back Alley Brute | Legendary Creature — Human Berserker | | |
| TMC | 23 | Electric Seaweed | Creature — Plant Wall | | |
| TMC | 24 | Fast Forward | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 25 | Shellshock | Instant | | |
| TMC | 26 | Special Move | Instant | | |
| TMC | 27 | Tempestra, Dame of Games | Legendary Creature — Elemental Illusion | | |
| TMC | 28 | Tokka & Rahzar, Unsupervised | Legendary Creature — Turtle Wolf Mutant | | |
| TMC | 29 | High Score | Enchantment | | |
| TMC | 30 | Leatherhead, Iron Gator | Legendary Creature — Crocodile Mutant Rogue | | |
| TMC | 31 | Level Up | Enchantment — Aura | | |
| TMC | 32 | Ninja Pizza | Enchantment | | |
| TMC | 33 | Rocksteady, Mutant Marauder | Legendary Creature — Rhino Mutant | | |
| TMC | 34 | Super Combo | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 35 | Double Jump // Flying Kick | Instant | | |
| TMC | 36 | Arcade Cabinet | Artifact | | |
| TMC | 37 | Big Mother Mouser | Artifact Creature — Robot | | |
| TMC | 38 | Coin of Mastery | Artifact | | |
| TMC | 39 | Exploding Barrel | Artifact | | |
| TMC | 40 | Mole Module | Artifact — Vehicle | | |
| TMC | 41 | Roadkill Rodney | Artifact Creature — Robot | | |
| TMC | 42 | Big Apple, 3 a.m. | Land | | |
| TMC | 43 | Hidden Hideout | Land | | |
| TMC | 44 | Together Forever | Enchantment | | |
| TMC | 45 | Vanquish the Horde | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 46 | Wave Goodbye | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 47 | Blasphemous Act | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 48 | Acidic Slime | Creature — Ooze | | |
| TMC | 49 | Biogenic Ooze | Creature — Ooze | | |
| TMC | 50 | Cultivate | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 51 | Harmonize | Sorcery | | |
| TMC | 52 | Steelbane Hydra | Creature — Turtle Hydra | | |
| TMC | 53 | Vigor | Creature — Elemental Incarnation | | |
| TMC | 54 | Voracious Hydra | Creature — Hydra | | |
| TMC | 55 | Assassin's Trophy | Instant | | |
| TMC | 56 | Corpsejack Menace | Creature — Fungus | | |
| TMC | 57 | Arcane Signet | Artifact | | |
| TMC | 58 | Chromatic Lantern | Artifact | | |
| TMC | 59 | Sol Ring | Artifact | | |
| TMC | 60 | Ash Barrens | Land | | |